Compare roof bids without reducing the decision to one number.
Enter up to five written proposals. The worksheet separates total price from scope completeness so missing permits, disposal, decking rates, warranties, and rooftop-equipment work are easier to spot.
Local-only worksheet.Your entries are stored in this browser. They are not sent to AZ Roof Estimator, a contractor, or the marketplace database.
Enter the proposals
Add only what is written in each contractor’s bid. Blank fields are useful because they reveal what still needs clarification.
Comparison summary
Price and proposal completeness are shown separately. A lower number is not a quality grade, despite humanity’s recurring effort to treat it as one.
Lowest entered price—
Average entered price—
Price spread—
Most complete entryBid A · 0%
| Proposal | Price | Material system | Warranty | Schedule | Permit / disposal | Decking | Completeness |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bid AUnderlayment not stated | Not entered | Not statedRooftop equipment scope not stated | Workmanship not statedManufacturer coverage not stated | Start not statedDuration not stated | Permit not statedDisposal not stated | Not stated | 0% entered |
| Bid BUnderlayment not stated | Not entered | Not statedRooftop equipment scope not stated | Workmanship not statedManufacturer coverage not stated | Start not statedDuration not stated | Permit not statedDisposal not stated | Not stated | 0% entered |
| Bid CUnderlayment not stated | Not entered | Not statedRooftop equipment scope not stated | Workmanship not statedManufacturer coverage not stated | Start not statedDuration not stated | Permit not statedDisposal not stated | Not stated | 0% entered |
Before selecting a contractor: ask for written clarification on every important blank or “not stated” item. Keep the answer with the proposal instead of relying on a conversation that will later evaporate from everyone’s memory.